� All On You | Main | Real Talent �
January 26, 2006
Black Blogging Revisited
A few months ago, Antoinette Pole from Brown University interviewed me and several other black bloggers. She presents her results.
This paper explores the role of black bloggers in the blogosphere. Among the top political blogs, blogging has primarily been undertaken by white men, coined by Chris Nolan as the "Big Boys Club." This research assesses how bloggers of color use their blogs for purposes related to politics, and it investigates whether the blogosphere facilitates political participation among black bloggers.The data for this paper are based on in-depth interviews with 20 black bloggers conducted in November 2005. Primarily exploratory, this paper examines the issues and topics discussed by bloggers of color, and whether and how bloggers are using their blogs to engage in political participation. In addition this research attempts to assess whether black bloggers face discrimination in the blogosphere. Findings from this research suggest that black bloggers do in fact use their blogs to encourage their readers to engage in various forms of political participation. Finally, the data also show that bloggers reported that they do not feel discriminated against or excluded by other bloggers.
Her focus on the politics of blogging and the blogging of politics tests three hypotheses:
Black bloggers will blog about issues related specifically to race. Black bloggers will use their blogs to engage in and to encourage their readers to engage in various forms of political participation that occur both online and offline. Black bloggers will report that they face discrimination by other bloggers.
The answer to 1 is yes, but how much? Indeed how much is too much or not enough. It's enough that we do, I suppose, but that doesn't necessarily mean that appropriate attention is paid. I think anyone who blogged primarily about race relations would go bonkers after three years if they weren't already bonkers. I say this from personal experience.
The answer to number two isn't a surprising yes, but one that after a moment's consideration, you'd expect. But I understand that this is the kind of baseline writing that must be done in order to build up a body of academic work.
The third answer is no. Black bloggers are, by and large, masters of their own domain. How black online writers got hounded out of public internet spaces was a function of the fact that they were squatters like everyone else. But when you control your discussion space, you can squelch the noise.
Dr. Pole presented her paper in India in December. You can read the whole thing: HERE. Of course you should. She makes a lot of good observations that are definitely worth considering.
Posted by mbowen at January 26, 2006 08:00 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.visioncircle.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4889
Comments
Thanks for posting this. I just discovered your blog today, and while I'm far from conservative, I think I'll at least check out what you have to say from time to time.
I'm very interested in reading about what's happening in the blogosphere, mainly because I think it's a powerful tool of expression, though it's interesting to observe its social and political effect and the direction it's going.
Anyway, after I read the paper, I might come back for further posts.
Posted by: Bakari at January 29, 2006 01:22 PM
Thanks for posting this. I just discovered your blog today, and while I'm far from conservative, I think I'll at least check out what you have to say from time to time.
I'm very interested in reading about what's happening in the blogosphere, mainly because I think it's a powerful tool of expression, though it's interesting to observe its social and political effect and the direction it's going.
Anyway, after I read the paper, I might come back for further posts.
Posted by: Bakari at January 29, 2006 01:22 PM
Just wanted to add that it's interesting how David Kline and Dan Burtein didn't touch on bloggers of color in their current book, Blog!: How the newest media revolution is changing politics, business, and culture. As will all forms of media, we again have to make our voices heard amongst the White dominate culture and class.
Posted by: Bakari at January 29, 2006 01:26 PM
I am not convinced that there is a great deal of change to be made by black politics. Rather the great change will be made IN black politics. It will become more conservative and its radicals will be moderated. Black politics will come to mirror American politics and then it will disappear altogether.
What blacks do in the blogosphere, I think, is indicative of that internal change. Why Kline and others are not noticing is the same reason nobody in particular is noticing. There isn't much impetus behind it. There is no black power movement, per se. Just as black Americans are getting wealthier, healthier and more educated, it is a silent evolution.
Progressives and liberals may try to make a great deal of hay over the significance of the marginalization of a sizeable black population. But I think they lack both the brainpower and allegiances to capitalize on this change in any significant fashion. They are both incapable of drafting into their ranks the numbers of capable people who would make something of this. And since the gains made by certain blacks in the middle class could be erased - and that is not particularly significant on a macro economic level, there is really nowhere for them to go. Where they would seek to racialize the economic fate of 10 or 15 million failing Americans, everybody else sees that all the time.
In other words, the economic impact of losing half of the black middle class is less than that of raising the price of a barrel of oil 50%. In light of the fact that oil prices are indeed rising at historical levels, nobody gives a crap about any racial politics progressives or liberals could cobble together (as if they could get 50% black voter turnout). So their efforts to politically capitalize on the fate of the despised Forty Percent (Cosby's enemies) is doomed even further.
Times are tough all over.
So what black blogs will do is reflect the inevitable internal change. But the consequences for the nation are generally subsumed into the bigger picture which is not particularly in need of a black perspective. The only people that read are the people who care about what P6 calls 'black intrapolitics'. That means you and me and maybe another 50k people who bother to read black political blogs daily.
I'm proud of my drops in that bucket. But I know it's a small bucket.