� A Minority Minority Party | Main | Because We Want to Know �
September 23, 2005
Word of Bond
I haven't been so quick to call blackfolks d dysfunctionally dependent on government largess (and scraps) as some Conservative bretheren. But nothing quite demonstrates the orientation of entitlement as the following mission statement:
We, the undersigned, vow to step up in the aftermath of Katrina, to ensure that no one is left behind again.We commit to doing our part to ensure that all people are regarded as full humans, not as second-class citizens, and that our government is responsive to their needs. We commit to helping those who have been continually ignored gain a powerful political voice.
We will insist that those who have been pushed to the margins become a priority in this country, and that the federal government take responsibility for people in crisis. We will hold the government, and ourselves, accountable.
Together, we will be a powerful force for change.
I'm not going to deconstruct this at length. I think it speaks for itself. If there is going to be a race and class discussion about Katrina then let us use Julian Bond's declaration stand in (for the sake of argument) for the cause of liberal, poor blacks. The fact that this will be popular and considered by its signers to be unassailable IS the 'unbridgeable' difference between them and the cause of conservative, rich whites, for whom Bush purportedly singularly loves. If and when I find such a manifesto on the other side of the fence, I'll plop it in here.
In the meantime here are some dichotomous talking points, personalized for the sake of Socratic dialog with the Kanye asslicks who are bound to follow.
I: Heard the news and got out of dodge when the mayor announced. You: Don't watch the news. I: Don't expect the President or other Government officials to care because they have no incentive to do better and they are largely incompetent bureaucrats.
You: Don't expect the President or other Government officials to care, because they are heartless, racist criminals who enjoy watching people suffer.I: Look at 60 Billion dollars in aid from the government as a boondoggle and an incredible opportunity to stimulate the entire economy of the region for blacks and whites alike.
You: Believe it's all going to Halliburton anyway, if it's even true.I: Am heartened by the generosity of Americans all over the country who have opened their arms, wallets and communities to displaced blackfolks who now have a chance to start over.
You: Are still looking for more dead bodies to amp up the volume of your complaints.I: Understand that nobody can be prepared for the inevitable slings and arrows and unpredictability of life.
You: Want safety and security at any cost to insure that 'this sort of thing never happens again'.I: Am satisfied that the overwhelming majority of people survived this ordeal and that valuable lessons have been learned.
You: Will continue to focus on those worst cases and use them to typify an inplacable and ongoing 'institutional bias' that will never change.I: Believe Kanye West is out of his depth, and is probably dumber than Tupac who wasn't too bright himself.
You: Believe that Kanye West inherits the mantle of Malcolm X, and that I should be shot for dissing 'Pac.I: Believe that most of the people who died in New Orleans were the elderly and infirm, and that this is similar in many ways to the people who die from heat exhaustion in Chicago, despite warnings by the mayor that they should drink plenty of water and stay by A/C.
You: Think that the Superdome was just a Nazi concentration camp or a slave ship in disguise.I: Am hoping that the displaced people can find the courage and assitance to move on with their lives.
You: Are hoping to build another MoveOn.com to make political points out of suffering by placing blame at the foot of GWBush.I: Am saying all this in anticipation of a provocative yet nuanced debate about the real political differences between Americans in matters of class and race.
You: Can't wait to call me names.
So this should be fun.
Posted by mbowen at September 23, 2005 02:19 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.visioncircle.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4414
Comments
Fatty.
(semi-inside joke for you non-VC readers)
Posted by: memer at September 23, 2005 03:39 PM
I'm curious to see how this goes, too. If anywhere. I'll sit on the sidelines for now.
But I'll just say that beyond pledging allegiance to a side or even (as is my usual stance) to picking one way or the other to tilt, I say this dichotomy can be like two independent dials, like bass and treble. Fine tune, 0-10 on each knob, for each song.
Posted by: memer at September 23, 2005 03:45 PM
I think you created dichotomist positions against the minority of minority positons Cobb.
BTW...I want to do an interview with you on the Conservative Brotherhood to post on my blog.
IE, why and how you started it. What it is intended for. Where you expect it to go. Etc.
Hit me up at dellgines@yahoo.com if you are down.
Posted by: Dell Gines at September 23, 2005 05:58 PM
Now, Cobb, you don't really want to go there. Are you saying you can't find statements from which whites about bending the government to the service of a particular constituency and then holding government accountable? Are you suggesting that if you could find something like that, you might stop spoutin' like Old UnFaithful? Or are you simply saying that the liberal/democrats are full of it? 'Cause if ya wanna have the rich white folk-government dependency conversation, we can start at the ROOTS and work through to JP Morgan and bring it home to your boy W. Lemme know if ya wanna go there. I don't think you do, but if you wanna, I'll pay for the gas and give you directions - you can drive.
Posted by: Temple3 at September 24, 2005 06:59 AM
You can ask the government, or God, for anything. That doesn't mean your demands are going to be met or that you are particularly righteous for making them. It seems to me that when you ask for the impossible from a pompous position, you are only setting up a precedent which wont be met so that you can continue to throw stones. In other words, Bond's is a cynical mission from the start, and deserves to be seen as such. Bond is saying, "If you don't buy me a bike for Christmas, you're a lousy parent."
As for JP Morgan, I do believe there's still a bank around with his name on it that's doing well for Americans. Yes I want to go there, there meaning where Bond is. I don't need to go back to 1895 when JP Morgan bailed out the US government to the tune of $62 millon. Then again, I can't expect an anti-capitalist to appreciate the uniqueness of that contribution to the infrastructure of America.
BTW. George W Bush is not my boy, he's the Republican party's boy. I'm a Republican, not a Bushie. Powell is more my boy, and so is Christie Whitman and John McCain.
Posted by: Cobb at September 24, 2005 09:26 AM
About five years ago, in a debate before the National Association of Black Journalists, I stated that if whites were to just leave the United States and let blacks run the country, they would turn America into a ghetto within 10 years. The audience, shall we say, disagreed with me strongly. Now I have to disagree with me. I gave blacks too much credit. It took a mere three days for blacks to turn the Superdome and the convention center into ghettos, rampant with theft, rape and murder.
Posted by: cnulan at September 24, 2005 11:24 AM
That's a reprehensible statement coming from an irresponsible loudmouth. Jesse Lee Peterson has demonstrated all of the restraint and discipline of a bulemic pig in a pastry shop. He's a ghetto minister who never left the ghetto in his mind. Too bad he's got so much airplay. Clearly he condescends to his audience - and he deserves whatever masochistic mobs vibe off his misanthropy.
Posted by: Cobb at September 24, 2005 11:45 AM
You know, you're right, you don't have to go back that far. We could go back to Enron. Pick a year - and there will some collective of wealthy white folk imposing their will on the government. It's not clear to me how the relative position of Bond as a beggar should be subject to more castigation. That his approach is "cynical" is a function of his powerlessness - not a function of the demand being made. There are far too many examples of government giving it up - you could look at the criminalization of hemp and the interests of William Hearst...take your pick. How about invasions and agri-business for $100? Daily-double?
Posted by: Temple3 at September 24, 2005 03:30 PM
Didn't mean to conflate your politics. I hear the nuances in your response. Still, the idea of petitioning government (Check out requests by a slave-owning dynasty during the 1927 flood in the Mississippi Delta, as another example. www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/flood/) I guess it's hard for me to understand why you have a problem with JB, aside from maybe some self-loathing due to undesired association with his powerlessness. I hope that's not it. Let me know. This is an interesting topic.
Posted by: Temple3 at September 24, 2005 04:15 PM
Yeah there is a reason Julian Bond is powerless and his brother in the Civil Rights Movement Vernon Jordan is powerful. That reason is significant. Bond wants to work against the capitalist system, Jordan works it. I have no need to associate myself in any way with Julian Bond. Although I seem to recall that in 1982 when I was a freshman computer science student at a conference at the Omni Hotel in Atlanta, he looked over the crowd I was sitting in and said essentially 'the world is yours'. So it's my world now.
As for Enron. Hey, they were a publically traded company. They got busted. The company was liquidated. The leaders were set to jail, and the economy didn't hickup. If slaves on the Enron plantation weren't clever enough to serve but one foul corporate master, then they are probably still unemployed to day. You cash your checks, you take your chances. That doesn't change anything. Next.
1927?