� The Sacred Feminine | Main | MS Mainframe �
November 17, 2003
Who Owns Black?
I do. I'm Old School. And if you want to fight about it, step out on the grass so I can kick your ass.
This is an attitude that I have found sadly lacking in my latest round of conversations with black men I respect and admire. I haven't talked to many black women about it, but I suppose that I will in time. You know who you are. Log in and speak up.
Doc mentioned a pimp that he busted last week. The pimp bounced up some assets and came up with bail or was sprung on a technicality. Who knows. But said black pimp tried to 'drop some science' on my brother about the idea that on the plantation, it was the black overseers who cracked the whip hardest. Pops underscored this observation with the problematic argument that I'm out to refute today and forever. Which is that 'we' have defaulted black culture to the lowbrow and that those, the least of my brothers, are keeping it more real and have a legitimate interpretation of race and history. In otherwords, that the pimp had a point and was within his rights to assert a racial brotherhood platform upon which he could criticize the cop who busted his lame ass.
Bullshit.
I cannot begin to express in a one way forum how opposed to this concept I am. The black experience continues to be interpreted by whitefolks in pop culture, wrongly, exactly as the black pimp says. What's real, via the majoritarian view of black culture, is 'Whazzap my nigga' and all you might imagine follows. But most crucially and gallingly, that blacks of refinement must heed those cultural guidlines because this is the best we can expect 'America' to recognize.
'The Reality of Black Life In America', goes the folk wisdom, is that the best a black man can expect is the same that the worst black man gets. I cannot sustain such an argument in my head. It is so lightweight that I can't even come up with it as a consistent strawman to defeat in my logic. And yet I know it has weight as an arguement because species of it's own twisted logic arises when I speak about being a Black Republican.
Ignorant thugs, pimps, hoes whatever rabble lowlife within African America cannot and will not persist with any special permanence. So how this is called 'black' despite what Black Consciousness is and was can only be a matter of skin color. The problem is that there is a false brotherhood based on skin color that African Americans are giving credibility.
Again I say that blackfolks need to do two things that are critical. The first is to adhere to their family and class identity and relationships with more ferocity than that to the fraternity of physical race. The second is that blackfolks need to fight losers, and stand in opposition to the lowbrow claims of ownership of 'black'. If you believe in Nelly's brand of black instead of Wynton Marsalis' version, then you are not on the right side of history, nor truth. Furhtermore if you're on that side, I'm looking to put you down.
I cannot see it any other way, and I'll grapple with anyone who dares disagree. At the same time, it's not crucial that I rescue 'black' from the grasp of the retarded crabs in the barrel. To have black associated with the lovely things like the creation of jazz and the interactivity of the christian liturgy and all the wonderful things we celebrate in black history month is gravy. Of course it's gravy I'd rather have, but on the whole it is not necessary. What is extraordinary and beautiful about life belongs to those who live it. It doesn't need to be black; history speaks for itself. We're all modern. We all appropriate.
But my history and the history of the Old School is real and righteous and if anyone deserves the mantle of what's admirable about 'black' it is those who adhere to those values. Pimps need not apply.
BTW. Read this.
And finally, I just learned a couple things that have rocked my little world a little bit and I thought I'd mention them here. The first is that there are only two HBCUs with accredited MBA programs. One of them is run by my boy David. The other thing is that John McWhorter speaks about a dozen languages. So I'm about to cut him some slack on his stifling style of writing in English. And furthermore I think he's on my side of the fence in this issue here.
Posted by mbowen at November 17, 2003 09:54 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.visioncircle.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1069
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Who Owns Black?:
� Mythical Deconstruction from The Mulatto Advocate
Cobb nailed it. I'm speechless. It reminds me of a situation I faced in college. I was working in a department store to help pay my way through college. A young black man came in one day. I recognized him... [Read More]
Tracked on November 18, 2003 01:56 PM
� Who owns "black"? from The Review
(Review) Cobb asks who owns black culture, and doesn't like the answers he finds. The black experience continues to be interpreted by whitefolks in pop culture, wrongly, exactly as the black pimp says. What's real, via the majoritarian view of... [Read More]
Tracked on November 18, 2003 05:15 PM
� Well Said from dcthornton.com
Cobb comments on the ownership of black culture:'The Reality of Black Life In America', goes the folk wisdom, is that... [Read More]
Tracked on November 19, 2003 12:03 AM
� Bear Flag Review from The Accidental Jedi
Why? 'Cause I feel like it. Thanks to BoiFromTroy for graciously allowing me to hijack the meme for a few minutes. He presented the last review in reverse alphabetical order, so this time why not start in the middle?... [Read More]
Tracked on November 19, 2003 07:43 AM
� How Are You Doing? from Unfogged
Michael Bowen examines "keeping it real." The black experience continues to be interpreted by whitefolks in pop culture, wrongly, exactly as the black pimp says. What's real, via the majoritarian view of black culture, is 'Whazzap my nigga' and all you... [Read More]
Tracked on November 20, 2003 01:03 PM
Comments
Hey, let's cut McWhorter some slack. I just picked up his latest book "Doing Our Own Thing" and he's an excellent prose stylist. Also, I think I see some kind of common theme between something like excellence in his book and what you're alluding to in this post. I've got to give it some thought.
Posted by: Peter Sean Bradley at November 24, 2003 10:43 PM
I still thing McWhorter protests too much. I'm always wary of blackfolks who think they have something to prove, and he often strikes me as that kind. But I'm not going to dog him any longer because I do believe his head is in the right place, even though he's a complete dork.
Without having read his books I am willing to guess that I have no substantial issues with McW, but I'd much rather hang around Zadie Smith.
Posted by: Cobb at November 24, 2003 11:46 PM